Tuesday, December 24, 2019

The Top 20 Best Metal Albums of 2019 by BeMetalways Editor


2019 brought us some huge comebacks such as Tool (after 13 years), Sacred Reich (after 23 years) and Candlemass with its original singer. Let's see where those landed on my list! Notably, this year we said (supposedly) goodbye to Slayer after their massive farewell tour. I caught them during the summer and it was awesome. I also saw their movie on the release day of the DVD in a movie theater, it was a unique experience. They will be missed!

As always the "listmania" tradition continues to inflate the internet and magazines around the world during the month of December. And I love them! I have compiled and aggregated 19 "best of 2019" lists posted in the last few weeks by major blogs and magazines. My conclusions were that the trend is similar from the last few years. While individual lists are very diverse, when you aggregate them the big names are winners (Tool, Slipknot, and Rammstein in 2019). Then you have the critics darlings such as Opeth and Baroness doing well. And finally the heavier, more underground and newer bands that everyone seems to include in their list. This year the chosen ones being Blood Incantation and Tomb Mold. Tool headed 4 of the 19 lists and is already part of many best of the decade lists as well. Below you can see if those bands made it to my own list.

Personally, 2019 was a very different year when it comes to how I handled, bought, listened and reviewed music. For starters, I finally gave in and fully adopted Spotify premium and that was the main driver for change. I bought much less CDs and I expect that moving forward, I will only buy CDs for some specific reasons. For example for completeness of some discographies. I did however bought still quite a few albums in vinyl. That will also go down as prices are going up, I'll be even more selective.

Another 2019 experiment that stuck was the way I managed this blog. Firstly, I created a schedule to review from 1 to 3 albums per week with 1 full review and the others as "quickies". That worked well and except for December and a week of vacations during the summer, every week a new review was posted. To cover the quickies, 4 quarterly compilations were posted covering those. In order to prioritize quality over quantity, I finally achieved my goal of reducing the number of albums that I listened in a year  to my goal of 100.

Finally, I posted other special reviews like important/best of songs, throwback reviews, best of a past year and discographies. Those are certainly kind of posts that I want to do even more in 2020. As I said, I expect that reducing buying physical copies will continue. On the other hand, going to concerts and supporting bands with merch purchasing and Spotify usage will consequently increase.

I hope you get something useful out of this, so seat back and enjoy the read!

50.In Flames - I, The Mask
49.Darkthrone - Old Star
48.Mayhem - Daemon
47.Fallujah - Undying Light
46.Steel Panther - Heavy Metal Rules
45.Abigail Williams - Walk Beyond the Dark
44.Obscure Infinity - Into the Vortex of Obscurity
43.Numenorean - Adore
42.Possessed - Revelations of Oblivion
41.Full of Hell - Weeping Choir
40.DragonForce - Extreme Power Metal
39.Death Angel - Humanicide
38.Queensrÿche - The Verdict
37.Children of Bodom - Hexed
36.Blind Guardian Twilight Orchestra - Legacy of the Dark Lands
35.Avatarium - The Fire I Long For
34.Abbath - Outstrider
33.Sanhedrin - The Poisoner
32.Misery Index - Rituals of Power
31.Baroness - Gold & Grey
30.Stormwarrior - Norsemen
29.Dream Theater - Distance Over Time
28.Periphery - Periphery IV: HAIL STAN
27.Amon Amarth - Berserker
26.Exhorder - Mourn the Southern Skies
25.Spirit Adrift - Divided by Darkness
24.Nile - Vile Nilotic Rites
23.Ray Alder - What The Water Wants
22.Insomnium - Heart Like a Grave
21.Whitechapel - The Valley

20.Gatecreeper - Deserted 
Deserted is the best new old/classic Death Metal (DM) album I listened to recently. Surprisingly the album opens with a NWOBHM-like intro as part of the title track that evolves into classic DM. Most tracks are groovy and mid-tempo such as the awesome "From the Ashes", sometimes flirting with Doom (e.g. "Sweltering Madness") and at other times picking up on hardcore speed (e.g. "Ruthless"). If you want classic no-frills DM with touches of Hardcore, you came to the right album.
19.Slipknot - We Are Not Your Kind
We Are Not Your Kind is a very tight, well-written record. I also like the fact that they experimented and tried new things. I do love the drumming, the production, Corey's performance, the guitar riffs and the fact that the sampling and scratching sounds are really reduced to the minimal needed. Why not higher on this list then? Because a lot of the songs sound very similar to each other and to previous records. It's a thin line between their signature sound and repetition. With that out of the way, what a great record!

18.Devin Townsend - Empath
Empath is a unique music experience. For a long time prog fan this album is a delight. It's like a modern heavy version of a classic 60's/70's prog rock band. The album flows like a walk through valleys and mountains, where the very heavy parts inject some adrenaline at times in contrast to some very soft moments. The symphonic elements are used with elegance. None of the choices in Devin's arsenal is overused, creating a very crazy but balanced musical experience. The very clear and dynamic production is another highlight. For less seasoned Devin fans, like me, I can see how it can get overwhelming as it can be noisy and chaotic at times, and it runs a bit too long. Hence why not higher.

17.Vanden Plas - The Ghost Xperiment - Awakening
Vanden Plas did it again, the band has no bad records in their 25-year old discography and Awakening is not changing that accomplishment. Old fans will dig this and for new ones this is as good as any Vanden Plas album. The band and musicians individually are highly underrated and this band should be getting much more attention from prog critics and fans. Breaking the double album into two, makes part one very digestible and pleasant.
16.Avantasia - Moonglow
Tobias Sammet continues to deliver great records under the Avantasia banner with another great power symphonic metal record that will add some amazing tracks to an already fantastic setlist to look forward to. As always, Tobby songwriting is great and tailored to the singers involved. In addition to old Avantasia voices, Moonglow also introduces new collaborators Hansi Kürsch of Blind GuardianKreator’s Mille Petrozza and Blackmore’s Night frontwoman Candice Night. Fantastic!
15.Killswitch Engage - Atonement
With 11 well-crafted, selected and sequenced songs in just 40 minutes, Atonement is a pure metal pleasure to listen to. The guitar work is superb and the vocals top notch. The bass and drums do a fantastic job holding it all together. The formula is not different from previous albums, great riffs, catchy melodies combined with hardcore heaviness and the balanced clean and screaming vocals. While Jesse's performance is probably his best on record, the album is elevated another notch by the two songs with guest singers: "The Signal Fire" (Featuring good old Howard Jones) and "The Crownless King" (Featuring Chuck Billy of Testament).

14.the Offering - HOME
I love good modern metal bands like the Offering that sound nothing like older bands and yet use metal elements that I learned to love over the years. The Offering does genre gymnastics like very few bands can do it and yet were able to create a signature sound with brutality, sing along melodies, fist pumping guitar riffs, headbanging grooves and complex arrangements. From the thrash nu metal extravaganza opener “Waste Away” to the epic 14-minute title track, HOME is intelligent, vigorous, uncompromisingly fresh and addictive. The best debut album of 2019.

13.Gloryhammer - Legends From Beyond the Galactic Terrorvortex
Terrorvortex is a worthy addition to Gloryhammer's discography following the same formula that got them here, but also creating a distinctive feeling. In terms of song writing, creating memorable melodies, hooks and catchy choruses, Legends from Beyond the Galactic Terrorvortex is as good as the band has ever been. There's no doubt that fans of the band will dig this and so will fans of symphonic power metal in general. I'm looking forward to see them live again and for their continued success. For the eternal glory of Dundee!

12.Arch/Matheos - Winter Ethereal
Winter Ethereal  was one of the best sonic experiences I had in 2019. The production is clear and well mixed. Yes, it could be shorter, but I don't really know where to cut it from. The guitar work, the emotions, the powerful and catchy singing, the song writing and drumming are all perfectly combined in a unique display of emotion and uncompromising creativity that only Arch/Matheos can deliver.
11.Candlemass - The Door To Doom
While it's pretty much a "back to the roots" album, The Door to Doom is not a retro affair. The production is modern, the vocals are powerful and clear (sometimes reminding of Jørn Lande or Dio). Throughout the record we can hear the diversity of Leif experiences influencing his song writing with precise execution and different colors out of Mr. Edling doom pallet. You can count as a comeback of Längqvist or as the newest release in almost seven years, the fact is the album is a superb addition to Candlemass' celebrated discography.


10.Swallow the Sun - When a Shadow is Forced into the Light
When a Shadow is Forced Into the Light is a grower. For the goth/post-rock songs and passages, you need time and focus to fully appreciate the emotions pouring from them. Mikko Kotamaki (vocals) performance is quite impressive on how he goes from beautiful clean singing into black metal screens, deep funeral doom growls with perfection. Musicianship and production are flawless. All in all, a few days may not be enough to fully appreciate this beautiful dark emotional record.

9.Cult of Luna - A Dawn to Fear
A Dawn to Fear is a huge accomplishing from the band following the masterpiece Vertikal. They prove themselves as a leading band within their genre. The result is an artistic musical journey difficult to digest but quite rewarding once you get your head around it. Experiencing it live, bumped this album much higher into this list. It's the perfect soundtrack for a cold and dark season.

8.Cattle Decapitation - Death Atlas
Death Atlas is a statement delivered via the metal music channel. It's an eclectic piece of extreme metal bringing influences from different sub-genres of Death/Black Metal and Grindcore. It's powerful, it's bleak and masterfully delivered.

7.Myrath - Shehili
Shehili was a pleasant surprise and a fantastic album to listen to. From song writing to production, Myrath delivers their unique take on power prog metal fused with Middle-Easter music with great musicianship and powerful catchy metal gems. Shehili has the potential to put this competent Tunisian band once and for all in the international prog map.

6.Soilwork - Verkligheten
The first big release of the year has been hovering my top albums list since January and it stood the test of time. Soilwork new phase has reached stability and creativity peak. People will recognize the musical elements this formation has created in the latest two albums, but they've taken the sound even further by trying new elements and not discarding the success of NFO. A powerful combination and one of their best albums. 


5.Beast In Black - From Hell With Love
From Hell With Love is a sequence of jewels fusing modern and retro 80's from start to finish. In this context, there are no bad tracks. Anton Kabanen is a master of creating catchy music and via Beast In Black he won't apologize or contain his love for the cheesiness of the 80s. I mean, if you grew up in that time, you won't believe that this album is being released 30 years later. His music writing combined with Papadopoulos vocals is a magical combination. In every song Papadopoulos displays his powerful and versatile pipes singing irresistible melodies that will get stuck in your mind. At the end of the day, the combination of love and believe in what you do with skillful song writer and talented musicians makes Beast In Black a breath of fresh air while paradoxically being retro. 




4.Sacred Reich - Awakening
Awakening is a thrash metal bonanza that feels to be straight out of the late 80's. I like the production values and specially what  Dave McClain delivers on the drums (that "Salvation" drum intro followed by the guitar riff is Sacred Reich's Painkiller). Mr. Rind voice apparently hasn't aged as he sings as well as back in the day. The album is straightforward and after just a couple of spins, I was singing along and fist pumping in the air. What else could I ask from a thrash record? An album that was highly anticipated is now highly recommended. 





3.Atlantean Kodex - The Course Of Empire
Atlantean Kodex makes epic doom metal by the book. Even thought there are intervals, the the album functions as one piece of music with one song flowing into the next perfectly. The production is dynamic and clear. The band uses several samples to immerse us into this medieval Europe of empires and kings. The musicianship is solid with a shout out to drummer  Mario Weiss. While the range and versatility of singer Markus Becker is rather limited, he has a beautiful voice and he is proficient within his boundaries to deliver a convincing performance. It helps a lot that the vocal melodies are epic, catchy and beautiful. 



2.Soen - Lotus
Albums like Lotus are the reason I keep checking more than 100 new releases every year. It’s that magical moment when you connect deeply with the music and find something truly special. There’s so much to like here, from the beautiful and yet powerful Joel Ekelöf's singing, the incredible drum work by Martin Lopez, one of the best bass sound I’ve heard in a while or the solid guitar riffs and solos. But Lotus is much more than a collection of great musicians, Soen is a band in harmony playing a complex but cohesive piece of music. At the end of the day the music writing is phenomenal and that makes all the difference.



1.Tool - Fear Inoculum
Tool delivered a uncompromising record, they are on that career stage in which they can do whatever they feel is right musically without worrying to please audiences. The band’s songwriting pushes and challenges listeners and it will take weeks or months to completely unpack this present. Initially I had a problem with Fear Inoculum because the first five songs run quite long and are very similar to each other. But I realized we can't take this album as a collection of singles because it's basically one long song. That's how Tool invite us to experience it. It will be interesting to see how the mainstream audience will react to this complex album where the only possible singles are over ten minutes long. While Fear Inoculum  didn't blew my mind at first, after a couple of months now it does every time I listen to it. 




Biggest Disappointments:
Crypt Sermon - The Ruins of Fading Light
Twisted Tower Dire - Wars in the Unknown
Astronoid - Astronoid

Favorite Album Cover Art:
Avantasia - Moonglow 
Cattle Decapitation - Death Atlas
Abigail Williams - Walk Beyond the Dark
Mgła - Age of Excuse
Blood Incantation - Hidden History of the Human Race

Favorite Guitar Solos:
Soilwork - The Nurturing Glance 
Dream Theater - Room 137 
Obscure Infinity - Grostesque Face 
Myrath - Darkness Arise 
Arch/Matheos - Never in Your Hands 
Suicidal Angels - D.I.V.A  
Tool - 7empest 
Crypt Sermon - The Snake Handler 
Exhorder - Asunder  
Opeth - Minnets Yta 
Ray Alder - The Killing Floor 

Top 5 songs:
Book of Shallows by Avantasia
Lascivious by Soen
7empest by Tool
Fall Into the Light by Dream Theater
Weightless by Evergrey

Favorite Shows:
Slayer at Graspop
Beast In Black at 013
Between the Buried and Me at Trix

Disappointing Shows:
Grand Magus at Graspop



Thursday, December 5, 2019

Quickies: Fourth Quarter 2019 Releases included GATECREEPER, AIRBOURNE, BLIND GUARDIAN and STORMWARRIOR

Between October 4th and December 6th, there were some very decent releases that didn't get a full review but deserved my attention anyway.

GATECREEPER Deserted (10/04)
Gatecreeper caught me completely by surprise. I was not anticipating this release but after reading good reviews and listening to the video single, I got interested in it. I can't comment how this album relates to the 2016's debut album, but Deserted is the best new old/classic Death Metal (DM) album I heard recently. Surprisingly the album opens up with a NWOBHM-like intro as part of the title track that evolves into classic DM. Most tracks are groovy and mid-tempo such as the awesome "From the Ashes" sometimes flirting with Doom (e.g. "Sweltering Madness") and sometimes picking up on hardcore speed (e.g. "Ruthless"). If you want classic no-frills DM with touches of Hardcore, you came to the right album.



AIRBOURNE Boneshaker (10/25)
Here a fun game for you, while listening to the 5th Airbourne album, try to match each song and/or riff to an AC/DC song. The band has never hidden their AC/DC worship and their debut album 2007's Runnin' Wild was breath of fresh air displaying a very fun and competent version of  good old 70's AC/DC. 2013's Black Dog Barking showed a bit of diversity and some other rock influences and I appreciated that. But by now the formula is wearing out and even the lyrics are not as fun as they used to be. Boneshaker is more of the same but it is fun. I'll continue to see Airbourne live as they put out a great show. I'll adjust my playlists accordingly and enjoy it very much. But a full album like this won't add much to me.



BLIND GUARDIAN TWILIGHT ORCHESTRA Legacy of the Dark Lands (11/08)
First things first, I thought it was a wise decision to launch this album with a slightly different band name. If you look on Spotify, it is not under the regular Blind Guardian discography. Why do I say that? Because despite the Blind Guardian feeling due to Hansi Kürsch vocals and similarity to their more symphonic songs, this is a soundtrack album and arguably not even metal. The most important musicians here are the Prague Filmharmonic and get this, there are no guitars whatsoever! With that aside, do I like it? Yes, I do. It sounds great and the band deserves a 10 out of 10 for the effort and ambitiousness. I can only imagine the complexity and hard work to put this all together.
It's impressive. Legacy of the Dark Lands is a concept album that takes a fusion of Nightfall and At the Edge of Time to a whole new level. It's a monumental project: 24 tracks in 75 minutes. But notice that 13 of them are narrations or short interludes. Which leaves us with 11 full anthems with unforgettable choruses. In that sense Hansi singing and the vocal melodies are pure Blind Guardian. On the other hand, I must say I spent 74 min waiting for those guitars to kick in and as they never did, I was left with a bittersweet taste.



STORMWARRIOR Norsemen (11/29)
This was quite a late surprise from a band that I did not know. But they have all the elements that make the part of my heart that melts for good power metal. We have Gamma Ray meets Iron Maiden with the spirit of Amon Amarth. And even though it reminds me a log of those bands, surprisingly it didn't bother me. It's well written, executed and catchy as hell. Songs like "Norsemen (We Are)", "Storm of the North" and "Odin's Fire" are already stuck in my head. The album follows my rules of a good album, just over 50 min, 8 proper songs, no ballads and even an 11 min epic closer. If you are into Viking Power Metal, you can't go wrong with this!



Sunday, December 1, 2019

Album Review: CATTLE DECAPITATION Death Atlas (11/29)

Cattle Decapitation is an extreme metal band from San Diego, California, formed in 1996. The line-up has suffered a few changes but Travis Ryan – vocals and Josh Elmore – guitars have been the driving forces and drummer Dave McGraw has already been with the band for 12 years. The bass has been less stable. In 2019 the band officially added a second guitar on the hands of  Belisario Dimuzio. Interesting fact, while the band started with an entirely vegetarian lineup, only two current members are vegetarian, namely Travis Ryan and Josh Elmore. No surprise that the band's lyrics are largely concerned with human impact on the environment, the ethics of eating meat and animal rights. Musically they started as really focused Grindcore but more recently Progressive Death Metal influences have become very prominent.

Death Atlas is the eighth studio album and comes more than four years after their masterpiece 2015's The Anthropocene Extinction. At just under 55 minutes, it is their longest album to date. 14 tracks (4 being intros/interludes) including the 9 min final title track. Vocalist Travis Ryan comments: "Musically and lyrically, there is a lot of grief, anger, hate, passion, and emotion poured into this one". I do like how they structured the album in basically 4 almost equal parts. Each one with an intro song full of samples of news reports. It's really difficult to define the metal sub-genre, we may as well just call it extreme prog metal. There's a little bit of everything: Melodic and Symphonic Black Metal, Tech Death, Deathcore, Death-doom, Thrash and even a hint of traditional heavy metal such as Accept.

Travis vocal is one of the most versatile in extreme metal today. From high pitched black metal screams to deep death metal growls and everything in between. The guitar work is focused on fast guitar picking and short but powerful solos. But you can also find some death metal riffs here and there. The drumming combines super fast blast beats and moments of more groove. The album is very dynamic with unconventional song structures.

I have not much to complain and there are only a couple of tracks that failed to catch my attention. And I must mention The title track being this "grand finale" of this bleak and dark album. It's a 9m15s epic closer.  I'd also highlight that I'm usually not a fan of intro tracks, but in Death Atlas they work well. Those 4 instrumentals break the brutality and give us a minute to breath. They also create those 4 parts which makes the album more digestible.

Death Atlas is a statement delivered via the metal music channel. It's an eclectic piece of extreme metal bringing influences from different sub-genres of Death/Black Metal and Grindcore. It's powerful, it's bleak and masterfully delivered.


SCORE: 82/100
Genre: Progressive Death Metal / Grindcore
Released by Metal Blade Records on November 29th, 2019

Follow BeMetalaways Spotify Playlist with upcoming metal releases

Rating System
98 - 100 Perfect
92 - 97 Excellent
86 - 91 Great
81 - 85 Very Good
77 - 80 Good
69 - 76 Mixed
58 - 68 Bad